Witness

Clive Naicker

Tow-truck operator, KwaZulu-Natal · Durban, KwaZulu-Natal

Testified 16 November 2026 · denies the allegation

A KwaZulu-Natal tow-truck operator who was named in evidence before the Madlanga Commission on 13 August 2026 (Day 158) by Gregory Loftus, the father of tow-truck operator Bevan Loftus, who told the commission his son 'was murdered by the police under the guise of a legitimate police operation and at the instance of Clive Naiker, a competitor of Bevan in the tow truck industry and alleged drug dealer'. The allegation sits alongside IPID's evidence the previous day that the task team's commander received more than R2.5 million from the owner of a tow-truck company between August 2022 and December 2023 and more than R2.7 million connected to the killing. He testified on 16 November 2026 (Day 195) and denied all of it: 'I can confirm that I did not conspire with anyone to murder Mr Loftus', 'I did not offer any reward to any persons, including police officers and officials, to murder Mr Loftus', and 'I've never had a relationship with Mr Loftus.' A ruling of the chairperson dated 15 November 2026 refused his application to have the whole of his evidence heard in camera and split it: his relationship with Loftus, his business activities and whether he paid moneys to police officers were heard in public, while his interactions with SAPS Crime Intelligence and the DPCI, and evidence touching court matters in which he is himself a witness, were closed and sealed. No court has considered any of this. He is presumed innocent, and nothing recorded here is a finding of any kind against him.

Clive Naickertow truckBevan LoftusKwaZulu-NatalMadlanga Commission

This profile summarises testimony and evidence given on the public record before the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry. It restates allegations as presented at the hearings and is not a finding of guilt, liability, or wrongdoing by any person.

Awaiting appearanceNo portrait on the public record yet

Their role

What the record says

Named as the person at whose instance the killing allegedly occurred

Gregory Loftus told the commission that his son was killed by police 'at the instance of Clive Naiker, a competitor of Bevan in the tow truck industry and alleged drug dealer'. This is an allegation made by a bereaved family member before a commission of inquiry. Naicker answered it on oath on 16 November 2026 and denied it in terms. It remains untested, no court has considered it, and he is presumed innocent.

The officer at the centre of the phase denies taking his money (Day 170)

On 31 August 2026 Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender, who commanded the task team named in the Morningside shooting, was questioned about his relationship with Naicker in open session after an application to hear the evidence in camera was refused. Per EWN he told the commission: 'My relationship with Clive Naicker is work-related. He assists with investigations. Um, I don't have a personal relationship with him, commissioner.' He acknowledged meetings with Naicker and with businessman Timmy Marimuthu, denied receiving any payment from Naicker, and denied Gregory Loftus's allegation that he authorised the killing on Naicker's behalf. Separately, chief evidence leader Advocate Matthew Chaskalson SC took Govender through 65 cash deposits totalling R1.7 million between August 2022 and December 2023 whose sources Govender attributed to a bank loan, family members and a businessman named Josh Chellin, not to Naicker. On 16 November 2026 Naicker answered the allegation himself and denied it. Everything here is untested and both men are presumed innocent.

His answer, on oath, on 16 November 2026 (Day 195)

Rewritten from the official 182-page transcript, published 17 November 2026. The evidence was led by Advocate Mpilo Sikhakhane and Advocate Teboho Mosikili, with Commissioners Sandile Khumalo SC and Sesi Baloyi SC questioning. Reading from his sworn statement in answer to a Regulation 10.6 notice: 'Insofar as Mr Bevan Loftus is concerned, I have confirmed that I did not conspire with anyone to murder Mr Loftus, and I did not offer any reward to any persons, including police officials, to murder Mr Loftus. I further confirm that I did not have any direct or indirect involvement in the assassination involving Mr Loftus or his mother.' On the recorded call, the record shows the accusation ran both ways. Commissioner Khumalo read him his own words from it: 'Who is this here? Who is this here? Bevan, you, you killed my uncle, you.' His uncle, named on the record as Mr Raju, was shot dead outside his house in November or December 2022, and Naicker volunteered that 'he was a known drug dealer'. On the figure he gave a towing-trade explanation absent from the reporting: 'I am not using the word million because why? ... in the tow truck industry if you indicate 2,5, you tell me you want your vehicle towed from point A to point B. I will tell you 2,5 which relates to me as 2,500.' He said the accusation on the call named two men, quoting Loftus as saying 'Puff and I are paying polices to get him killed'. He accepted three calls with a man he says he never met, gave an innocent account of the first two, and conceded one shared turning point on the N2 where both businesses could pick up. He denied gang membership and drug trafficking: 'I am not a member of no gang. The only gang I am a member of is the one in my house.' He conceded that people within the towing industry are involved in drugs while denying that the trucks move them. He denied making any payment to the police officers named to him and denied receiving any payment from SAPS Crime Intelligence or any state body. At the close Advocate Mosikili put it to him that the account he gave journalists omitted the alleged bounty, the repeated accusations and the naming of Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender, and differed materially from the recording. He agreed: 'I would have to agree according to what I see', and undertook to obtain the journalist's recording and file a supplementary affidavit. All of it is untested and he is presumed innocent.

A 2025 High Court harassment application was put to him in open session (Day 195)

Advocate Mpilo Sikhakhane put to Naicker a High Court application dated 23 May 2025, brought by Visham Panday against Naicker as first respondent and one Avista Ramkissoon as second. It sought orders interdicting the respondents from assaulting or threatening the applicant, from causing harm to him or his family, from harassment, and from 'enlisting the assistance of any third party' to do so. The founding affidavit alleges that at about 17:30 on 20 May 2025 Naicker telephoned and 'repeated his threat that he would kill me unless I paid the second respondent the full amount claimed', that he said his contacts at the Hawks meant the applicant's own Hawks contacts could not help him, and that he repeated the threat on 21 May 2025. A confirmatory affidavit from one Shahida Hendricks is attached. Naicker denied it flatly: 'It is untrue. The allegations brought against me is untrue. We defended these allegations.' He said the call arose because a woman had come to him saying Panday had taken a large sum from her, and that Panday 'went ballistic'. Asked whether he had contacts in the police he could enlist for an unlawful purpose, he answered 'No.' These are untested allegations in civil proceedings. Mr Panday has given no evidence to this commission and has not answered Naicker's counter-account of him; neither account has been tested. Both men are presumed innocent.

Timeline

How the account unfolded

12 August 2026

IPID puts figures on the table (Day 157)

Len Barnabas John of IPID told the commission that the commander of the task team received more than R2.5 million from the owner of a tow-truck company between August 2022 and December 2023, and more than R2.7 million connected to the killing. Naicker was not named in that evidence.

13 August 2026

Named by the father of the deceased (Day 158)

Gregory Loftus told the commission his son was killed 'at the instance of Clive Naiker, a competitor of Bevan in the tow truck industry and alleged drug dealer', and alleged a payment of more than R2 million. The commission played a recording of a January 2023 call in which Bevan Loftus confronted Naicker about a 2.5 on his head.

31 August 2026

Govender denies taking his money (Day 170)

Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender told the commission that his relationship with Naicker was 'work-related', denied receiving any payment from him and denied authorising any killing on his behalf.

11 November 2026

An in camera application is published with the name withheld

The commission published an application headed 'In camera application of witness to appear on 16 November 2026'. The applicant was not named in the published bundle.

15 November 2026

The application is refused in part

The chairperson ruled that two categories of his evidence be heard in camera - his interactions with SAPS Crime Intelligence and the DPCI, and evidence touching court matters in which he is a witness - and that three be heard in open session: his relationship with Bevan Loftus and whether he was involved in events that may have resulted in the killing, the nature of his business activities, and whether he paid moneys to police officers and why.

16 November 2026

He testifies and denies the allegation (Day 195)

A full working day in open session, led by Advocate Mpilo Sikhakhane and Advocate Teboho Mosikili. He denied conspiring to murder Loftus, denied offering any reward to any police officer, and said he had never met him. The official transcript shows the recorded call carried accusations in both directions: Loftus accused him of putting a price on his head, and he accused Loftus of killing his uncle, Mr Raju, who was shot dead outside his house in late 2022 and whom Naicker described on the record as a known drug dealer. He explained the figure 2,5 as towing-trade shorthand for a R2 500 tow. He conceded one shared turning point on the N2 where both businesses could pick up. He denied gang membership and drug trafficking. At the close he agreed that the account he had given journalists differed from the recording and undertook to file a supplementary affidavit.

17 November 2026

His evidence resumes in camera and is sealed

The Day 195 record closes with the chairperson's direction, 'Let us resume in camera at 09:30 tomorrow', and the line 'HEARING POSTPONED TO 17 NOVEMBER 2026'. The sealed portion covers his interactions with SAPS Crime Intelligence and the DPCI, and the court matters in which he is himself a witness. Under the chairperson's ruling of 15 November 2026 that evidence may not be publicly disclosed without a further ruling of the commission or an order of a court. This archive holds no part of it.

On the stand

Appears on 1 hearing day

  1. Day 19516 Nov 2026

On the record

1 commission document names this witness

Connections

How this witness links to the record

Alleged tow-truck rival of the deceased

Bevan Loftus

Tow-truck operator and taxi owner, Durban; killed by a SAPS task team in 2023

Named by the deceased's father as a competitor in the tow-truck industry and as the person at whose instance the killing allegedly occurred. The official Day 195 transcript shows the recorded call between them carried accusations in both directions: Loftus accused Naicker of putting a price on his head, and Naicker accused Loftus of killing his uncle. Untested; presumed innocent.

View profile →
The witness who named him

Gregory Loftus

Former police officer; father of Bevan Loftus

Gregory Loftus's Day 158 evidence is the source of the allegation recorded on this page. Naicker answered it on oath on Day 195 and denied it. Untested on both sides; presumed innocent.

View profile →
The officer alleged to have been paid by a tow-truck owner

Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender

Head of the Hawks' KwaZulu-Natal provincial tracing team; former commander of the province's cash-in-transit task team, South African Police Service

IPID alleged that the task-team commander received more than R2.5 million from the owner of a tow-truck company between August 2022 and December 2023. On Day 170 Govender denied any payment from Naicker and described their relationship as work-related and not personal. On Day 195 Naicker denied offering any reward to any police officer. Both denials are on the record; untested, and both men are presumed innocent.

View profile →
The IPID investigator whose evidence quantified the payments

Len Barnabas John

Deputy director for investigations, Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID), KwaZulu-Natal

Len John's evidence of 12 August 2026 put more than R2.5 million from a tow-truck company owner to the task-team commander between August 2022 and December 2023, and more than R2.7 million connected to the killing. Naicker answered that evidence on 16 November 2026 and denied it. Untested.

View profile →
The firearms expert who questioned the police account

Ashley Houston

Retired captain, South African Police Service; firearms expert

Houston attended the Morningside scene and told the commission on 13 August 2026 that the officers' account of the shooting was 'highly improbable'. His evidence goes to how the five men died, not to who, if anyone, procured it.

View profile →