Witness

Tamryn Raju

Phoenix resident, KwaZulu-Natal; relative of the witness Clive Naicker · Phoenix, KwaZulu-Natal

Killed 17 November 2026 · no arrests

A 32-year-old mother shot dead inside her home in Shastri Park, Phoenix, on Tuesday 17 November 2026, the day after her relative Clive Naicker gave public evidence to this commission and the day he was due to resume behind closed doors. Her 13-year-old daughter, who has special needs, was in the house. Per Daily Maverick, a private security company that responded found a damaged door and the woman inside with multiple gunshot wounds. KwaZulu-Natal police opened a murder docket. SHE WAS THE DAUGHTER OF THE MAN AT THE CENTRE OF THE RECORDED CALL. On Day 195 Naicker told the commission that his uncle, named on the record only as Mr Raju, had been shot dead outside his house weeks before the January 2023 call in which the two men accused each other, and he volunteered of him: 'Well, he was a drug dealer. He was a known drug dealer.' Per Daily Maverick and IOL, that man was Elvis Raju, Tamryn Raju's father, shot dead in Phoenix. The reporting dates his killing to January 2023; Naicker's own evidence put it in November or December 2022. This archive records both and reconciles neither. IN THE DAYS BEFORE SHE DIED SHE WAS PUBLICLY CONTRADICTING THAT ACCOUNT. Per Daily Maverick and IOL she posted on TikTok about the commission and about her father's killing, disputing the claim that Bevan Loftus was responsible for it and saying he had been framed. That is the opposite of what Naicker told the commission on the recorded call, in which he said to Loftus: 'Bevan, you, you killed my uncle, you.' She also posted a clip of Naicker testifying that he was not a gang leader, and, on 8 November, a screengrab carrying a photograph of Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender. NO LINK IS ESTABLISHED. Per Daily Maverick the motive is not yet clear. Per SABC News, police spokesperson Robert Netshiunda said the circumstances surrounding the shooting, including what led to it, will form part of the investigation. Per Daily Maverick, police spokesperson Captain Ntathu Ndlovu said: 'The circumstances surrounding and leading up to the shooting will form part of the investigation', and 'No arrests have been made as yet, as investigations are under way.' No person has been arrested, charged or named by police. The claims she made in her posts are unverified and this archive does not repeat the allegations she made against living people. Nothing here is a finding against anyone.

Tamryn RajuRajuPhoenixKwaZulu-NatalClive NaickerElvis RajuMadlanga Commission

This profile summarises testimony and evidence given on the public record before the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry. It restates allegations as presented at the hearings and is not a finding of guilt, liability, or wrongdoing by any person.

Awaiting appearanceNo portrait on the public record yet

Their role

What the record says

What is established

A 32-year-old woman was shot dead inside her home in Shastri Park, Phoenix, on Tuesday 17 November 2026. Her young daughter was in the house. A murder case has been opened by KwaZulu-Natal police, no arrests have been made and no motive has been established. SABC News reported the killing on 18 November without naming her, describing the victim only as a relative of the businessman Clive Naicker; Daily Maverick, IOL, Eyewitness News and others named her. Those are the facts the outlets agree on.

What is a line of investigation and not a fact

Every outlet that has reported this killing has placed it next to the commission, because of the timing and because of who she was related to. None of them asserts a connection, and nor does this archive. Police have said only that the circumstances leading up to the shooting form part of the investigation, which is what police say about any killing. Her social media activity in the preceding days is a documented fact; that it caused her death is not. Treat the two as separate until an arrest or a court says otherwise.

Her account of her father's death contradicted the witness's

This is the part that matters to the record rather than to the crime. On the official Day 195 transcript Naicker's position is that Bevan Loftus killed his uncle, a belief he attributed to 'word on the street' rather than to evidence, and which he advanced while rejecting allegations made against himself on the same basis. Per Daily Maverick and IOL, the dead man's own daughter was publicly saying the opposite: that Loftus had been framed. She is not a witness and her account was never tested by anyone. Its significance is that the man's closest family did not accept the account given about him from the stand.

Timeline

How the account unfolded

Nov or Dec 2022, or Jan 2023

Her father is shot dead in Phoenix

Naicker told the commission on Day 195 that his uncle, Mr Raju, was shot dead outside his house weeks before the January 2023 call, and described him on the record as a known drug dealer. Per Daily Maverick and IOL that man was Elvis Raju, her father, and the reporting dates the killing to January 2023. The two dates are not the same and this archive does not choose between them.

5 to 9 Nov 2026

She posts about the commission and about her father's killing

Per Daily Maverick she posted repeatedly on TikTok in the preceding fortnight, including a clip of Naicker testifying that he was not a gang leader and, on 8 November, a screengrab carrying a photograph of Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender. Per IOL she disputed the claim that Bevan Loftus was responsible for her father's death and said he had been framed. Her claims are unverified.

16 Nov 2026

Naicker gives public evidence (Day 195)

Her relative spent a full working day in open session denying that he conspired in the killing of Bevan Loftus. The record of that day includes his account of her father's death.

17 Nov 2026

She is shot dead at home

Killed inside her house in Shastri Park, Phoenix, with her daughter in the home. The same day, Naicker was due to resume his evidence before the commission behind closed doors. No arrest has been made.

18 Nov 2026

Police confirm the killing

KwaZulu-Natal police confirmed a murder investigation and said the circumstances leading up to the shooting form part of it. No motive has been established and nobody has been named.

Connections

How this witness links to the record

Her relative, and the witness whose account of her father she disputed

Clive Naicker

Tow-truck operator, KwaZulu-Natal

Per SABC News she was a relative of Naicker; per Daily Maverick and IOL she was the daughter of the uncle he described from the stand on Day 195. In the days before she was killed she publicly disputed his account that Bevan Loftus was responsible for her father's death. She was killed on 17 November 2026, the day after his public testimony. No link between the two things has been established by anyone, no arrest has been made, and nothing is alleged here against him.

View profile →
The man she said had been framed for her father's killing

Bevan Loftus

Tow-truck operator and taxi owner, Durban; killed by a SAPS task team in 2023

On the Day 195 record Naicker accused Loftus of killing his uncle, on 'word on the street' rather than evidence. Per IOL, the dead man's daughter publicly rejected that, saying Loftus was framed. Loftus was himself shot dead on 1 April 2023, one of five men killed in the Morningside shooting now before this commission, and never answered the accusation. Both accounts are untested.

View profile →
Named in a post she published on 8 November 2026

Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender

Head of the Hawks' KwaZulu-Natal provincial tracing team; former commander of the province's cash-in-transit task team, South African Police Service

Per Daily Maverick, one of her posts carried a screengrab showing a photograph of Lieutenant-Colonel Govender. The post's claims are unverified and are not repeated here. Govender has denied receiving any payment from Naicker and denied authorising any killing on his behalf, and is presumed innocent. Nothing connects him to her death and nothing of the kind is alleged.

View profile →