Madlanga Commission hearing record

Day 195 of the Madlanga Commission

Witness: Clive Naicker

Evidence led by Advocate Mpilo Sikhakhane, Advocate Teboho Mosikili

The 182-page official transcript landed the next morning and it is a different day from the one the bulletins reported. On the recorded call at the centre of this case the accusation runs both ways: Bevan Loftus accused Clive Naicker of putting a price on his head, and Naicker accused Loftus of killing his uncle. Naicker denied conspiring in the killing, denied paying any officer, and offered a towing-trade explanation for the figure 2,5 that no outlet carried. By the close an evidence leader had put to him that his account to journalists differed materially from the recording, and he agreed. The commission then sealed the doors and resumed in camera the next morning.

Awaiting portrait

The day in brief

What you need to know

  • NOTHING ON THIS PAGE IS A FINDING. Mr Naicker is not an accused person before any court on this matter. He came to this commission under an allegation made by a bereaved father in August 2026, he has now answered it under oath and denied it in terms, and no court has considered any of it. Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender, who is alleged to have taken his money, has separately denied it. Every other person named below has answered nothing on this record. All are presumed innocent.
  • THIS PAGE WAS REWRITTEN FROM THE OFFICIAL 182-PAGE TRANSCRIPT, published on 17 November 2026, and the official hearings row for Day 195 now exists and confirms the date. Two holds this archive carried are retired by the record: the evidence leaders are ADVOCATE MPILO SIKHAKHANE and ADVOCATE TEBOHO MOSIKILI, and the commissioners' questions are now given in their own words rather than in the reporting's paraphrase. The content of all three calls is on the record, which retires the single-outlet hold this archive placed on the first two.
  • THE ACCUSATION ON THE CALL RUNS BOTH WAYS, AND NO OUTLET REPORTED THE SECOND HALF. The commission read Naicker his own words from the recording: 'Bevan, you, you killed my uncle, you.' His uncle, Mr Raju, was shot dead outside his house in November or December 2022, some weeks before the call. Asked about him, Naicker volunteered on the record: 'Well, he was a drug dealer. He was a drug dealer. He was a known drug dealer.' The call is not a man receiving an accusation. It is two men accusing each other.
  • HIS EXPLANATION OF '2,5' IS A TOWING-TRADE EXPLANATION, AND IT IS NOT WHAT THE BULLETINS CARRIED. Verbatim: 'I am not using the word million because why? The call was made to me as 2,5, so at that time it was confusing whether it was 2,5 because in the tow truck industry if you indicate 2,5, you tell me you want your vehicle towed from point A to point B. I will tell you 2,5 which relates to me as 2,500.' The record also shows the accusation on the call named two people, not one: 'Puff and I are paying polices to get him killed.'
  • THE SHARPEST MOMENT OF THE DAY WAS A CONCESSION ABOUT THE PRESS, NOT ABOUT THE KILLING. Advocate Mosikili put it to him that the account he gave journalists omitted the bounty, omitted that Loftus repeatedly accused him of wanting him dead, and omitted that Loftus had specifically named Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender. Asked whether his published account differed from the recording, Naicker answered: 'I would have to agree according to what I see.' He said he would instruct his legal team to obtain the journalist's recording and file a supplementary affidavit.
  • AN EVIDENCE LEADER DISCLOSED A LIVE LINE OF INVESTIGATION FROM THE FLOOR. Advocate Mosikili, on the record: 'one of the things that we are looking into now as a fact is the fact that we are also questioning his financials because there is an allegation that monies will be offered, and we are looking into his finances to check if there were any monies received by him that he can explain post this killing.' That is the commission stating, in open session, that it is examining Lieutenant-Colonel Govender's finances. Govender has denied receiving anything from Naicker.
  • HE WAS ASKED TO ACCOUNT FOR THIRTEEN NAMED PEOPLE AND NINE MORE, AND DENIED A RELATIONSHIP WITH ALMOST ALL OF THEM. Among the police named to him: Colonel Swastika Govender (whom he identified only as a police officer and the spouse of Lieutenant-Colonel Govender), Constable Kevin Sithal of Mayville SAPS, Captain Deeno of Sydenham SAPS, Captain Pedro Rodrigues, Major General Senona, Major General Kana and former Police Minister Bheki Cele. He denied making any payment to Constable Sithal or his family, and denied receiving any payment from SAPS Crime Intelligence or any state body.
  • A HIGH COURT HARASSMENT APPLICATION AGAINST HIM WAS PUT TO HIM IN OPEN SESSION. Dated 23 May 2025, brought by Visham Panday against Naicker as first respondent and Avista Ramkissoon as second, it alleges that Naicker telephoned on 20 and 21 May 2025 and threatened to kill him unless a sum was paid, and that he invoked contacts at the Hawks. Naicker's answer: 'Not true', 'I have never mentioned that to him', and asked whether he had police contacts he could enlist for an unlawful purpose, 'No.' The application is an untested allegation in civil proceedings; Mr Panday has given no evidence to this commission.
  • THE CHAIRPERSON PRESSED THE INDUSTRY ON ITS OWN BODY COUNT AND NAICKER DID NOT DISPUTE IT. Madlanga: 'We heard evidence of how people are killed left, right and centre ... in this industry. I was shocked. I was surprised and shocked. Do you confirm that?' Naicker: 'I hundred percent confirm that.' But when the chairperson put to him that the killers could not only be the few he called cowboys and must include the organised majority, he declined: 'I would disagree on that.'
  • WHAT WAS SEALED IS STILL THE HALF THAT MATTERS MOST TO THIS COMMISSION'S MANDATE. The chairperson's ruling kept his interactions with SAPS Crime Intelligence and the DPCI, and the court matters in which he is himself a witness, behind closed doors. The record ends 'HEARING POSTPONED TO 17 NOVEMBER 2026', with the chairperson's direction: 'Let us resume in camera at 09:30 tomorrow.' There will be no public record of that sitting.

Full coverage

The day, in depth

What the transcript changes, and why this page was rewritten

This archive published Day 195 on the evening of 16 November 2026 from six news reports, and flagged three holds on its own work: that the evidence leaders were unnamed, that no outlet carried a verbatim commissioner quotation, and that the content of the first two of Naicker's three calls with Bevan Loftus rested on the Mail and Guardian alone. The official 182-page record, published the following morning, retires all three and does something more awkward: it shows that the single most important fact about the recorded call was absent from every report read for the original page. The bulletins reported a man being accused. The record shows two men accusing each other. The evidence leaders were Advocate Mpilo Sikhakhane, who led the morning, and Advocate Teboho Mosikili, who closed the afternoon. Naicker was represented by Advocate C J van Schalkwyk SC of the Pietermaritzburg and Durban Bar, on the instructions of Arvina Harrichavan Attorneys. He was sworn, not affirmed, and he gave his evidence by reading a sworn statement prepared in answer to a Regulation 10.6 notice, paragraph by paragraph, with the chairperson directing that each question be read aloud first because the answers made no sense without them.

The ruling that split the day, and how it was announced

The chairperson dealt with the in camera application before the first question, and the record shows it had been decided the previous night: 'there was an application for Mr Naicker's testimony to be in-camera, and I made a ruling last night that it should be partly in-camera and partly in open session. So we are going to start with that part, which will be in open session, and as soon as we are done, we will then break to resume in-camera.' The signed ruling, dated at Pretoria on 15 November 2026 and signed by Commission Secretary Dr N Vukuza, orders two issues closed: 'the nature of his interaction with members of the SAPS Crime Intelligence and DPCI' and 'the evidence relating to court going matters in which Mr Clive Naicker is currently a witness'. Three are ordered open: his relationship with Bevan Loftus and whether he was involved in events that may have resulted in the killing, the nature of his business activities, and whether he paid moneys to police officers and why. He had applied for all of it to be closed. The record also shows the housekeeping that follows such a ruling: the chairperson warned counsel to keep the two halves apart, 'so that you do not let slip inadvertently what should be in-camera', and later directed that the statement itself not be displayed on the public feed, because 'just below what we flight may be a description of the relationship about somebody that he should not testify about in open session'.

The call, read back to him, with both accusations in it

The commission did not replay the audio. It took him to the transcript of it in the bundle, and the passage Commissioner Sandile Khumalo SC chose was not the one the news carried. At line 17 of page 106 it is Naicker speaking: 'Who is this here? Who is this here? Bevan, you, you killed my uncle, you.' Asked what he was referring to, he said that in November or December 2022 his uncle was shot and killed outside his house. The uncle is named on the record as Mr Raju. Naicker then volunteered, unprompted, the thing that gives the exchange its weight: 'it was quite surprising. I mean, he had no enemies, even though he did a little bit of things that he should not be doing. Well, he was a drug dealer.' Pressed, he repeated it twice: 'He was a drug dealer. He was a known drug dealer.' He said he had not employed his uncle in any capacity. Later, Commissioner Khumalo returned to a published interview in which Naicker had said he heard on the street that the uncle's shooting was a case of mistaken identity and that he himself was meant to be the target. He rejected the rumour on physical grounds: 'I did not believe that it is mistaken identity because I look very far away from my uncle. My uncle was a healthy-looking elderly person. He was in his early 60s. So I do not think anyone would have mistaken him for me.' Advocate Mosikili later gathered the whole exchange up and put its character to him: on that call Loftus accused Naicker of arranging his killing and of paying people to target him; Naicker accused Loftus of killing his uncle and of spreading allegations that Naicker had had a man named Reagan killed. 'And those are serious exchanges between two people, and you would have to agree with me that that is a confrontation.' Naicker: 'That was a confrontation. I would have to agree with you, yes.'

What he says 2,5 meant to him

His account of the call's substance is fuller on the record than in any report, and it turns on trade shorthand. Asked by Commissioner Khumalo how the last call came about, he answered: 'I would not know how the call came about but I would answer that Mr Bevan Loftus called me and he asked me about some 2,5 put on his head, that Puff and I are paying polices to get him killed and so on and so on. I denied the allegation because it is not true.' Two details in that sentence were not in the bulletins. The first is that the accusation on the call named two men, him and 'Puff', a reference to the late Brendan Kalicharan, known as Puffs, who appears in the commission's own list of people Naicker was required to account for. Naicker later made the point himself when the proposition was put to him that he was the man accused: 'the recording identifies two people, you and Puff', and 'Bevan had a relationship with Puff. Him and Puff were acquaintances at one stage in their life, so I cannot really, I can just speak for myself.' The second is his explanation of the figure: 'I am not using the word million because why? The call was made to me as 2,5, so at that time it was confusing whether it was 2,5 because in the tow truck industry if you indicate 2,5, you tell me you want your vehicle towed from point A to point B. I will tell you 2,5 which relates to me as 2,500. So, at that time when he mentioned 2,5 on my head, it was a bit confusing. I was trying to understand the conversation and then I realized who I am talking to and I asked him okay, you want to have a conversation, let us have a conversation, not in those words, and he obviously did not give me an opportunity to speak. He said what he had to say and he cut the call.' Whether that is believable is not for this archive to say. It is recorded because it is his explanation and because no outlet carried it.

Three calls, and the one concession on competition

All three calls are now on the official record, which retires the single-outlet hold this page previously carried on the first two. Naicker's account: 'I have had three calls from Mr Loftus in the time he has been an operator with us for KZN. I have never seen him directly. I have never met him directly. I have never spoken to him face-to-face. I have never knew where he resided.' The first call, he said, was Loftus asking to use his towing company's name, because insurers would not let unaffiliated operators stand off at accident scenes: 'with good faith, I did tell him, yes, you can contact my office and the ladies at my office would assist these drivers.' The second arose from an accident on the N2 where Loftus's truck instructed Naicker's driver to drop a loaded vehicle: 'I told him, okay, no problem ... we will tow the vehicle but we would pay his driver for the vehicle. So, I am not sure what was the amount that was being paid at that time but it ended up well.' The third is the recorded one. On competition, the chairperson pressed him directly. 'You were competitors in business, were you not?' Naicker: 'I would, no, we were not.' 'Was he not in the towing, car towing business?' 'Yes, he was.' 'Are you not also in that same business?' 'Yes, I am.' 'Are you not competitors therefore?' 'We share different areas ... he is in the south, I am in the central. So we are not in competition with one another in the towing industry.' Then the qualification that is the only ground he gave all morning: 'There is no way that we can clash on an accident scene. We have one common turning point only, and that is just about it.' Under further questioning he explained that the point is the Edmund Street off-ramp, the only place to turn from the northbound carriageway to the southbound, that the accident in question happened there, and that it was an area where both could 'jointly pick up'. The chairperson's scepticism is on the record: 'I am lost as to how, what you have just explained now-now would arise ... if, as you clearly stated, your areas of operation were clearly defined, clearly demarcated to the extent that you said you were not competitors.'

The drug allegation, put to him from the IPID evidence

Commissioner Khumalo took him to page 8 of the statement of the IPID investigator the record calls Mr John, and read it to him: 'As I show below, there is at least a prima facie case that at the instance of Mr Clive Naicker, the alleged leader of a drug and tow trafficking gang, Lieutenant Colonel Deena Govender deployed task teams to kill Mr Bevan Loftus, who was the alleged leader of a rival drug and tow truck gang.' Naicker's objection was definitional before it was factual: 'we hear about gangs. Every gang has a name. I have not been identified. I have been identified as a gang leader, but I have never been identified as the name of the gang. So I would not accept the allegations made against me because, firstly, I am not a gang leader for me to have a gang.' Asked whether he was a member of a gang: 'I am not a member of no gang. The only gang I am a member of is the one in my house.' Asked whether he was involved in drug trafficking: 'No, I am not.' The commissioner then read the wider proposition, that tow trucks move drugs because their operators are 'police friends' and are waved through roadblocks. Naicker: 'Confidently, I can tell you no', and on whether the witness was wrong: 'If he has evidence to prove otherwise, I would not disrespect his allegation. But as far as I know ... the tow truck business is not there for drug-related issues.' He added that where the evidence leaders had put specific persons or organisations to him who are involved in drugs and own tow trucks, he could not answer for their vehicles' movements because he had no facts, but could speak confidently for his own business. The distinction he was drawing matters and he did concede one half of it. Pressed by Advocate Sikhakhane on whether people within the towing industry are involved in drugs, as opposed to whether tow trucks are used to move them, he answered: 'People within the tow truck industry involved in drugs ... Yes, yes. My answer would be yes.' The chairperson tested where that left his earlier evidence: 'I thought the thrust of the evidence was about the tow trucks themselves being used in drug trafficking ... but a point you made was that it was not what I loosely referred to as the organised group ... it was the cowboys who did this. Was I wrong in my understanding of your testimony?' Naicker: 'I could have admitted to the owner of the operation being involved in drugs, and I identified that I have no circumstances as being aware of any tow trucks, even whether it belongs to cowboys or whoever, that have been publicly known to have been stopped and have been searched and seized with drug trading.' So: people in the industry, yes; the trucks as a trafficking channel, not to his knowledge; himself and his own business, no.

The industry, the body count and the braai stand

The longest passage of the day is Naicker on his own trade, and the chairperson did not let him keep it romantic. Madlanga: 'I think you were a bit euphemistic about how new entrants enter and some of the old entrants have exited. We heard evidence and I was shocked. We heard evidence of how people are killed left, right and centre ... in this industry. I was shocked. I was surprised and shocked. Do you confirm that?' Naicker: 'I hundred percent confirm that and that was one of the reasons why the structure was put together, to bring peace and stability in the industry. That owners of towing companies should not be getting killed. Drivers should not be getting shot or shot at.' He placed the blame on what he called cowboys and on new entrants: 'Gangsters and drug dealers should not be coming out and empowering themselves and using that strategy of coming and overpowering business people that have created the industry.' He answered the label he knows attaches to him: 'I am going to say yes, people speak about me that I muscle and gangster but there is not a single case open against me or my company, not even an assault case except the one for drag racing.' Then the elegy, which is worth keeping because it tells you what the man thinks he lost: 'The industry used to be beautiful the most beautiful thing you could have ever enjoyed on a weekend, take your braai stand, your cooler box sit on a tow truck, patch under a tree, run the accident, laugh, guys have a few drinks, put some meat on the braai stand, it used to be an amazing, amazing, amazing towing business until the cowboys came out and the shootings and killings started.' The chairperson refused the frame twice. 'Surely it cannot be the cowboys only that are involved in the shooting', and then, fully: 'my understanding is that the so-called cowboys are few in number and that the vast majority are the people who are organised. And so I am suggesting to you that it must be the people who are within the organised body who must be killing each other left, right and centre. Your comment?' Naicker: 'I would disagree on that.' He declined to name the legal entities controlling the areas he works, and gave his reason: 'the last time my name was mentioned in this Commission I think I have lost some major funds to insurance companies having disagreements with the Commission's status or allegations made against me.'

The thirteen names, and the nine

A large part of the public session was the methodical reading of a Regulation 10.6 notice and his answers to it. The commission required him to explain his relationship with thirteen people at paragraphs 2.3.1 to 2.3.13 and nine more at 2.5.1 to 2.5.9, and to say whether he had paid them, benefited them, paid their families, or hosted them at named addresses. On the police: of Colonel Swastika Govender he said 'I have no relationship or association with this person. I am, however, aware that she is a police officer, and is a spouse of Lieutenant Colonel Govender.' Of Constable Kevin Sithal: a Mayville SAPS officer he knew by sight from accident scenes, 'I have no relationship and/or association.' Of Captain Deeno, after initially answering that he had no relationship, he corrected himself when Commissioner Baloyi asked whether he knew him: 'Captain Deeno was a member of Sydenham SAPS. He has been a member of Sydenham SAPS for as long as I can remember. He as well used to attend accident scenes, and we got to know one another.' Of Captain Pedro Rodrigues, Major General Senona and Major General Kana: no relationship or association. Of former Police Minister Bheki Cele: 'I have no relationship or association with the former Minister, I am however aware of who he is due to the position of being the Minister via media.' He confirmed he made no payments to Constable Sithal, in cash, electronically or otherwise, made none to his spouse, children or relatives, and 'I confirm I did not receive payments from the South African Police Services Crime Intelligence or any state.' On the civilian list: he said the late Brendan Kalicharan, known as Puffs, 'was never my friend or associate', met casually on about five occasions, and that it was the late Malcolm Kalicharan he knew, from drag racing events. He said Lenny Vincent Pietersen is a taxi operator he knows through SANTACO KZN meetings. He said Krian 'Rounder' Pillay was his employee at Roadstar Auto Recoveries from 2011 to 2022, a driver and manager demoted to driver in late 2017. He said Colin Naidoo is chairman of the Chatsworth Association. He said Mr Panganathan 'Timmy' Marimuthu was introduced to him in 2013 by a friend over a property sale. Of several others, including Daine Majority, the late Simone Jasmin known as Queen of the South, and Yunus Essop, he said they were unknown to him. One name on the official list carries a racial slur as a nickname; this archive reproduces the name without it.

The High Court application he was asked to explain

Advocate Sikhakhane put to him a High Court application dated 23 May 2025, brought by Visham Panday against Naicker as first respondent and one Avista Ramkissoon as second. The relief sought was read into the record: orders interdicting the respondents from assaulting or threatening to assault the applicant, from causing harm to him or his family or inspiring a reasonable belief that harm might be caused, from conduct amounting to harassment, and, at paragraph 4.2, 'from enlisting the assistance of any third party to engage in any conduct referred to'. The founding affidavit alleges that at about 17:30 on 20 May 2025 Naicker telephoned and 'repeated his threat that he would kill me unless I paid the second respondent the full amount claimed', that he said that because of the people he knew at the Hawks the applicant's own Hawks contacts would not be able to assist him, and that on 21 May 2025 at about 09:30 he telephoned and 'once again threatened to kill me unless I paid the second respondent the full amount'. A confirmatory affidavit from one Shahida Hendricks is attached. Naicker's answer was a flat denial: 'It is untrue. The allegations brought against me is untrue. We defended these allegations.' His account of the call was that a woman had come to him for assistance saying Panday had taken a large sum from her, and that he telephoned Panday to ask about it and 'he went ballistic'. He characterised the litigation as a pattern: 'Open up High Court applications against anyone that he does not want to speak to', and noted drily that 'for me even speaking this on the public air, I will receive an application tomorrow as well. So I got to watch my words carefully.' Asked whether he had contacts in the Hawks he could enlist for an unlawful purpose, he answered 'No.' The application is an untested allegation in civil proceedings and it is recorded here as such. Mr Panday has given no evidence to this commission and his allegations have not been tested before it; Naicker's counter-account of him has not been tested either, and Mr Panday has not answered it.

The close: what he told journalists, and what the recording says

Advocate Mosikili spent the final hour on a published interview, and the method was simple: read what he told a journalist, then read what the recording shows. He had told the press 'I have never met Bevan. I am the biggest player in the tow trucking industry in KZN. I own 40 vehicles. My drivers are not violent. I am trying to make the industry peaceful', that Loftus 'was a thug, an evil young man', that 'word on the street is that he killed 40 people in Wentworth, Newlands and Sydenham', that 'he accused me of lots of things, but I never had a confrontation with him', and on the police: 'The cops dealing with these matters are seasoned. They are hawks, and they do their job well. People cannot bribe them with a few R100. They will arrest you.' Advocate Sikhakhane had already tested the basis for calling a dead man evil: 'Was Bevan arrested for that?' 'No.' 'So why do you say he was responsible?' Mosikili then listed the omissions. He had not mentioned that Loftus repeatedly accused him of wanting him killed: asked why, 'No, there is no reason why.' He had not mentioned the alleged bounty: 'No, there is no reason why.' He had not mentioned that Loftus specifically accused him of paying Deena Govender to have him killed: 'No, I did not mention it because it was not true.' And he had told journalists he never had a confrontation with Loftus, having just agreed that the call was one. Mosikili put the conclusion: 'your account of events, it differs, or it is not complete when you compare what you told the media and what actually transpired in the actual conversation.' Naicker: 'I would have to agree according to what I see', adding that he would instruct his legal team to obtain the journalist's recording and 'submit a supplementary affidavit on that'. On the bribery line he retreated: asked what he meant that the Hawks cannot be bribed with a few hundred rand, and whether he was suggesting they could be bribed with more, he said twice, 'It was a figure of speech', and 'I never thought that it would become a weapon against me.'

Curfew, and a line of investigation disclosed from the floor

Two things at the very end are worth separating out. The first is a loose end from an earlier witness: Mosikili raised a restaurant called Curfew, which the retired SAPS captain Ashley Houston had told the commission Naicker owns, and asked whether police are given free food or drinks there. Naicker said he does not own it, holds no shares, and has one association with it: 'The owner's husband is a friend of mine.' The second is more significant, because it is the commission describing its own work. Explaining why she was pressing him on cash transactions, Mosikili said: 'this Commission is also about inquiring into the influence that people might have, or at least undue influence that they might have with the police, and that is why we are asking you these questions.' And then, on Lieutenant-Colonel Govender: 'this Commission is also trying to question Colonel Deena Govender as to exactly if he was involved ... and one of the things that we are looking into now as a fact is the fact that we are also questioning his financials because there is an allegation that monies will be offered, and we are looking into his finances to check if there were any monies received by him that he can explain post this killing.' Naicker said he had seen it and that 'I know what is going on about Deena Govender. It is public knowledge', but that 'from my side, I have got nothing to do with that. I have not given Deena Govender no monies. I have not offer to pay anyone any monies for anything concerning Bevan Loftus.' Mosikili closed the subject: 'We are dealing with Mr Govender to explain some of those transactions, and only he can explain that.' Lieutenant-Colonel Govender denied receiving any payment from Naicker when he gave evidence on 31 August 2026, and is presumed innocent.

What closed behind the doors, and what happened next

The public session ran the whole working day and the sealed portion did not begin until it was over. The record's final direction is the chairperson's: 'Let us resume in camera at 09:30 tomorrow. Let us adjourn.' The transcript then closes with the line 'HEARING POSTPONED TO 17 NOVEMBER 2026'. What goes on behind those doors is defined by the ruling and not by anyone's discretion on the day: his interactions with SAPS Crime Intelligence and the DPCI, and the evidence relating to court matters in which he is currently a witness. The second is the ordinary protection given to a person who is a witness in live criminal proceedings. The first is the one that matters to the subject of this commission. If the question before this inquiry is whether criminal networks have been woven into the police, then the relationship between a businessman named in a murder allegation and the division of the police that runs informants is close to the centre of it, and that is the part the public will not see. This archive records the existence and the boundaries of that evidence and nothing of its content, because it has none and is not entitled to any.

In their words

Key moments from the record

“Who is this here? Who is this here? Bevan, you, you killed my uncle, you.”
The accusation nobody reported: he accused Loftus back. Commissioner Advocate Sandile Khumalo SC reading Naicker his own words from the transcript of the recorded call, at page 106, line 17 of the commission's bundle. Every report of this day carried Loftus accusing Naicker. None carried this.
“It was quite surprising. I mean, he had no enemies, even though he did a little bit of things that he should not be doing. Well, he was a drug dealer. He was a drug dealer. He was a known drug dealer.”
The uncle. Naicker explaining the accusation, 16 November 2026. His uncle, named on the record as Mr Raju, was shot dead outside his house in November or December 2022, weeks before the call. The volunteered detail is his own, not the commission's.
“I am not using the word million because why? The call was made to me as 2,5, so at that time it was confusing whether it was 2,5 because in the tow truck industry if you indicate 2,5, you tell me you want your vehicle towed from point A to point B. I will tell you 2,5 which relates to me as 2,500.”
What 2,5 means in a tow truck. Naicker to Commissioner Khumalo, giving the explanation of the figure at the centre of this case that no outlet carried. He is not denying the call happened. He is saying he did not at first understand it as money at all.
“Insofar as Mr Bevan Loftus is concerned, I have confirmed that I did not conspire with anyone to murder Mr Loftus, and I did not offer any reward to any persons, including police officials, to murder Mr Loftus. I further confirm that I did not have any direct or indirect involvement in the assassination involving Mr Loftus or his mother.”
The denial, read from his sworn statement. Naicker reading paragraph 12 of his statement in answer to question 2.6 of the Regulation 10.6 notice, which asked whether he conspired with anyone to murder Bevan Loftus or offered a reward to anyone, including police officials, to do so.
“I am lost as to how, what you have just explained now-now would arise ... if, as you clearly stated, your areas of operation were clearly defined, clearly demarcated to the extent that you said you were not competitors.”
The chairperson will not accept the demarcation. Justice Madlanga, after Naicker said he and Loftus were not competitors because they worked different parts of KwaZulu-Natal, and then described a shared turning point on the N2 where an incident between their drivers occurred.
“We heard evidence of how people are killed left, right and centre ... in this industry. I was shocked. I was surprised and shocked. Do you confirm that? ... I hundred percent confirm that.”
The industry's body count, confirmed by the witness. Justice Madlanga putting to Naicker what the commission has heard about the towing industry from earlier witnesses in the KwaZulu-Natal strand.
“My understanding is that the so-called cowboys are few in number and that the vast majority are the people who are organised. And so I am suggesting to you that it must be the people who are within the organised body who must be killing each other left, right and centre. Your comment?”
The chairperson refuses the 'cowboys' frame. Justice Madlanga, after Naicker blamed the violence on a small number of new entrants he called cowboys and defended the established operators. Naicker's answer was: 'I would disagree on that.'
“We hear about gangs. Every gang has a name. I have not been identified. I have been identified as a gang leader, but I have never been identified as the name of the gang ... I am not a member of no gang. The only gang I am a member of is the one in my house.”
Not a gang leader, for want of a gang's name. Naicker to Commissioner Khumalo, answering the IPID evidence that there is a prima facie case that Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender deployed task teams to kill Bevan Loftus at Naicker's instance, Naicker being described there as the alleged leader of a drug and tow trafficking gang. He denied gang membership and drug trafficking outright.
“Your account of events, it differs, or it is not complete when you compare what you told the media and what actually transpired in the actual conversation. You agree with me that there are differences and some things are not mentioned? ... I would have to agree according to what I see.”
The concession that closed the day. Advocate Teboho Mosikili, after taking Naicker through the omissions from the account he gave journalists: the alleged bounty, the repeated accusations, and the naming of Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender. Naicker said he would instruct his legal team to obtain the journalist's own recording and file a supplementary affidavit.
“One of the things that we are looking into now as a fact is the fact that we are also questioning his financials because there is an allegation that monies will be offered, and we are looking into his finances to check if there were any monies received by him that he can explain post this killing.”
The commission says what it is doing with the money. Advocate Mosikili, in open session, describing a live line of the commission's own investigation into Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender. Govender denied receiving any payment from Naicker when he testified on 31 August 2026 and is presumed innocent.
“I think it was just a figure of speech. I said it out the way I felt it at that given time. I never thought that it would become a weapon against me.”
A figure of speech about bribing the Hawks. Naicker retreating from his own published remark that the Hawks officers on the case could not be bribed 'with a few R100'. Advocate Mosikili asked whether he was implying they could be bribed with more.
“Let us resume in camera at 09:30 tomorrow. Let us adjourn.”
The doors close. The chairperson's final direction on the record, after a full working day in open session. The sealed portion of Clive Naicker's evidence began the following morning and no public record of it will exist.

Our analysis

The bottom line

The transcript is a lesson in what a day's reporting cannot carry, and this archive is one of the outlets it caught out. Every report of 16 November, and the first version of this page, described a man answering an accusation. The record shows an exchange in which both men accused each other of murder, and in which the witness volunteered that his own murdered uncle was a known drug dealer. That is not a detail. It is the difference between a one-way allegation and a feud, and a feud with a dead relative on the other side of it is a different evidential object altogether. It cuts both ways, which is precisely why it belongs on the page: it supplies Naicker with an explanation for his hostility that is not a contract killing, and it supplies the commission with a motive it did not previously have on the public record.

His explanation of the figure deserves to be set out rather than smirked at. The case against him has been shorthanded for three months as the R2.5 million hit, and the only contemporaneous evidence of that figure is a man saying '2.5' on a telephone call. Naicker's answer is that in his trade 2,5 is a tow quote of R2 500, and that the call made no sense to him until he worked out who was speaking. It is a convenient explanation and it is also, on its face, a coherent one. Whether it survives the commission's scrutiny is not for this archive to say. What the archive can say is that the public was told he denied knowing what a 2.5 was, and was not told what he said a 2,5 is.

The day's real damage was not done on the killing. It was done on the press. Advocate Mosikili's closing sequence did not try to prove that Naicker arranged anything; it proved that the version he gave journalists omitted the bounty, omitted the repeated accusations, omitted the naming of a police officer, and asserted that there had never been a confrontation with a man he had just agreed he had confronted. He conceded the discrepancy in terms. A commission weighing credibility does not need a confession when it has a witness agreeing that his own public account was incomplete, and his undertaking to obtain the journalist's recording and file a supplementary affidavit is now a thing the record will expect to see.

A line of investigation was disclosed in open session that is larger than the witness who prompted it. An evidence leader said, on the record, that the commission is examining Lieutenant-Colonel Deena Govender's finances for monies received after the killing. That is a statement about where this strand is going, made by the people taking it there, and it is more informative than anything the day's witness said. Govender has denied receiving anything from Naicker. The two denials now stand side by side with a financial inquiry running underneath them, and the inquiry, not the denials, is what will decide it.

The structural fact of this page has not changed and should not be allowed to recede behind the detail. A full working day of public evidence was spent on a dead man, a tow-truck territory and a bank account, and then the doors closed on the part that touches Crime Intelligence and the DPCI. The commission exists to inquire into criminality and corruption inside the criminal justice system. The portion of this witness's evidence that speaks directly to that is sealed, and the public record of it is one line in a ruling and a direction to resume at half past nine. There may be excellent reasons. The archive's job is to keep the shape of the hole visible.

Analysis is the archive’s own comment on the public proceedings, grounded in the record above. It weighs the evidence and the process; questions of individual guilt are for the courts and the commission to decide. Everyone named is presumed innocent.

Follow the threads

Who Clive Naicker connects to

Alleged tow-truck rival of the deceased

Bevan Loftus

Named by the deceased's father as a competitor in the tow-truck industry and as the person at whose instance the killing allegedly occurred. The official Day 195 transcript shows the recorded call between them carried accusations in both directions: Loftus accused Naicker of putting a price on his head, and Naicker accused Loftus of killing his uncle. Untested; presumed innocent.

View profile →
The witness who named him

Gregory Loftus

Gregory Loftus's Day 158 evidence is the source of the allegation recorded on this page. Naicker answered it on oath on Day 195 and denied it. Untested on both sides; presumed innocent.

View profile →
The officer alleged to have been paid by a tow-truck owner

Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender

IPID alleged that the task-team commander received more than R2.5 million from the owner of a tow-truck company between August 2022 and December 2023. On Day 170 Govender denied any payment from Naicker and described their relationship as work-related and not personal. On Day 195 Naicker denied offering any reward to any police officer. Both denials are on the record; untested, and both men are presumed innocent.

View profile →
The IPID investigator whose evidence quantified the payments

Len Barnabas John

Len John's evidence of 12 August 2026 put more than R2.5 million from a tow-truck company owner to the task-team commander between August 2022 and December 2023, and more than R2.7 million connected to the killing. Naicker answered that evidence on 16 November 2026 and denied it. Untested.

View profile →
The firearms expert who questioned the police account

Ashley Houston

Houston attended the Morningside scene and told the commission on 13 August 2026 that the officers' account of the shooting was 'highly improbable'. His evidence goes to how the five men died, not to who, if anyone, procured it.

View profile →