Madlanga Commission hearing record

Day 197 of the Madlanga Commission

Witness: Anthony Winston Sehas +1 more

Evidence led by Advocate Motlhasedi, Advocate Thabang Pooe

The official 222-page record of the 19 November sitting landed the next morning and it is sharper than any bulletin from the night. An IDAC investigator described, on oath, a travel memorandum that named no prisoner, a 700-kilometre prison transfer in standard VW Polos with no escort of any kind, a stop outside a hotel to collect a chief investigator at eleven at night, forty-five minutes in a stationary car outside a McDonald's that he could not account for, and a team released at the prison gate without ever signing the prisoner back in. Then a JMPD chief superintendent sat through three clips of her own voice describing a cash handover she now says never happened, and told the commission she had lied under oath because she had learned she was dealing with a syndicate. The chairperson asked her directly whether she was in it.

Awaiting portrait

The day in brief

What you need to know

  • NOTHING ON THIS PAGE IS A FINDING. Mr Sehas is a witness and nothing is alleged against him. Mr Perumal and Mr Padayachee were suspended in July 2026 pending disciplinary processes, which are employment steps and not findings, and neither has answered this evidence from the witness box. Chief Superintendent Rikhotso has been convicted of nothing; both the allegation she came to answer and her answer to it are untested. Mr Matlala is an accused person who denies the charges against him. Everyone named is presumed innocent.
  • THIS PAGE IS WRITTEN FROM THE OFFICIAL 222-PAGE TRANSCRIPT, not from the reporting. The official hearings row published on 20 November 2026 confirms the number, the date and both witnesses: 'Witness : IDAC Investigator Anthony Winston Sehas. Evidence Leader : Adv Motlhasedi. Witness : JMPD Chief Superintendent Rikhotso. Evidence Leader : Adv Pooe.' SABC's Day 197 label, which this archive held as one outlet on the night, is the official number. Three holds carried here are retired by the record: the Sheraton stop, the handcuff question and the recording played to Rikhotso are all now on the public transcript.
  • THE TRANSFER WAS AUTHORISED BY A DOCUMENT THAT NAMED NOBODY. Sehas drafted the travel memorandum and Chief Criminal Investigator Dylan Perumal signed the approved version. It gave a case number, Silverton CAS 285/3/2026, and the single word investigation. It did not name Mr Matlala, did not say a prisoner was to be moved and did not state the nature of the matter. Commissioner Sesi Baloyi SC put the consequence to him: the Director of Administration who approved it 'would not have known that she is, in fact, approving the transportation of a Correctional Services person'. Sehas: 'No, Commissioner.' His explanation was that 'the memorandum passes through a lot of hands, so it is also a way of protecting information'.
  • HE WAS TAKEN TO EBONGWENI BY TWO TACTICAL UNITS AND BROUGHT BACK BY NOBODY. Sehas's statement records that a SAPS Tactical Response Team and the Correctional Services Emergency Support Team had moved Matlala to Ebongweni the weekend before. Commissioner Sandile Khumalo SC put the asymmetry to him: 'Mr Matlala was taken from Mampuru by a Tactical Response Team and an Emergency Support Team. But when he comes back, it is just VW Polos.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'That is concerning.' Sehas: 'It is, Commissioner.' He confirmed handcuffs and leg irons, standard unarmoured vehicles, and that no other law enforcement agency was told the convoy was on the road.
  • 'TERRIBLY WRONG' WERE THE COMMISSIONER'S WORDS AND SEHAS ACCEPTED THEM. The exchange on the record is three lines. Khumalo SC: 'So would you say what was done on that day is consistent with the protocol that you are aware of?' Sehas: 'No, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'Something went wrong.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'Terribly wrong.' Sehas: 'Yes, yes, Commissioner.' The reporting of the night carried the phrase as his concession, which it is, but the words were put to him.
  • THE FORTY-FIVE MINUTES ARE NOW LOCATED, DATED AND PLACED. The convoy reached Pretoria after 23:00, pulled over on the island before the Jean Avenue off-ramp, and was told by Padayachee 'that we needed to go to the Chief quickly'. It stopped in front of the Sheraton Hotel in Arcadia only long enough for Perumal to get in, 'maybe stationary for 45 seconds' on Sehas's account, then drove to the McDonald's on Skinner Street in the Pretoria CBD. There Perumal, Padayachee and Matlala stayed in one stationary vehicle for about forty-five minutes while the rest of the team ate behind their cars. Sehas: 'We do not know what, if anything, was discussed because we were out of the vehicle.' Kgosi Mampuru II was four or five kilometres away.
  • NOBODY WHO SIGNED HIM OUT SIGNED HIM BACK IN, AND THE COMMISSION STILL DOES NOT KNOW WHAT TIME HE WAS BOOKED IN. Sehas and Padayachee co-signed the Correctional Services release form at Ebongweni. At the Kgosi Mampuru gate around midnight, Padayachee told the team 'that the Chief, referring to Chief Perumal, thanks us for a job well done and that we were being decommissioned'. Everyone went home. Advocate Motlhasedi told the record: 'the Commission has made, has taken steps to try and obtain information about what time Mr Matlala was received at C-Max. We have not yet received that confirmation as yet.' Matlala's own evidence is that he was booked in at four in the morning. Sehas says it was around midnight and that he keeps written times. Neither account is tested.
  • A NAMED CLIQUE INSIDE IDAC NOW HAS TWO WITNESSES, NOT ONE. Sehas's statement says 'a certain quarter of IDAC generally worked amongst themselves and tightly controlled the flow of information'. Asked whether that was the same grouping Advocate Drushantha Ramsamy had described to this commission as the Eastern Cape team, he said: 'It could be. It is the members that comes from the Eastern Cape.' Asked who, he named five officials from his own paragraph 36. The characterisation is an allegation about an informal working group, not a finding about any individual, and nobody he named has answered it here.
  • RIKHOTSO SAT THROUGH FOUR CLIPS OF HER OWN VOICE. The commission obtained, late the previous night, the recording of her 2023 interview with DPCI investigator Captain Manda. In it she says 'I went and take the money with the police, the investigating officer', describes collecting cash in a plastic bag, handing it to a Hawks captain who put it on the passenger seat under a laptop bag, and says the money was to be distributed to the head of the Hawks and a magistrate. She told the commission every bit of it was untrue, dictated to her by Inspector Emma Phakoane and a DPCI officer she named only as Carlo. Advocate Pooe's difficulty, put to her repeatedly, was that she repeated the same account to this commission's own investigators in 2026, from memory, without the statement in front of her.
  • SHE DESCRIBED A ROBBERY SYNDICATE AND THE CHAIRPERSON ASKED IF SHE WAS IN IT. Pressed on what she had been afraid of, she said: 'I found out that this is a syndicate that involves a lot of people.' Asked for its method: 'They wait for them. The informers tell them the time they victim will be driving or passing in this and they target them, they stop them and they rob them.' She said it ran across JMPD and the Hawks. Justice Madlanga: 'You are so, so not forthcoming and self-contradictory... Are you, is this not because perhaps you yourself are part of the syndicate?' Rikhotso: 'I am not part of the syndicate.' Madlanga: 'As if you would admit if you were, would you?' She wrote names she would not speak aloud and handed them to the commission; none is on the public record and none is here.

Full coverage

The day, in depth

What the transcript adds, and what it corrects

This archive published the 19 November sitting on the night as two profiles and a development, with no day page, because the official hearings table still reached Day 195 and SABC's 'Day 197' was a single outlet. The official row published on 20 November 2026 settles it, and the 222-page transcript published the same morning settles three further things this archive had deliberately held. The Sheraton Hotel in Arcadia, carried on 19 November as The Citizen's detail alone for this journey, is verbatim on the record. The handcuff divergence, where Eyewitness News reported that Sehas could not confirm Matlala was cuffed and three other outlets reported that he had, is resolved in favour of the three: asked 'Was he cuffed?' Sehas answered 'Yes, Commissioner, with leg irons and handcuffs', and separately said he could not say whether the cuffs were loosened or moved to the front inside the car he was not travelling in. Both reports were describing different answers to different questions. And the recording played to Rikhotso, carried on 19 November as Sowetan's account alone and deliberately not described here, was played in open session and is transcribed in full. One correction to this archive's own page: the man Eyewitness News reported as 'Mr Khobeni', who got out of the car at the McDonald's, is Financial Investigator Phaleni Ngobeni on the official record.

The morning: a court appearance that did not happen, and a memorandum that said nothing

Sehas's involvement began with a phone call on the evening of 6 April 2026 asking him to collect Senior Criminal Investigator Brian Padayachee from OR Tambo the next morning, because Matlala was due in court on 7 April. They drove to Kgosi Mampuru II at nine and were told Matlala was not there: a SAPS Tactical Response Team and the Correctional Services Emergency Support Team had moved him to Ebongweni the previous weekend. They went to the Pretoria Specialised Commercial Crimes Court on Visagie Street, where the matter was on the roll; Sehas stayed outside with the vehicles and does not know whether a warrant issued. Back at the prison the head of the centre refused to accept the requisition and J7 warrant for a man no longer held there. By three in the afternoon the team was back at the IDAC offices in Brummeria for a meeting Perumal had called by telephone, and the decision was taken to fetch him. Perumal asked Sehas to draft the travel memorandum. It was addressed to the Director of Administration, Ms Adelle De Swardt; it named eight officials, three NPA-issued vehicles and the case number Silverton CAS 285/3/2026, described as an IDAC authorised investigation, and it said nothing else. The chairperson asked the obvious question first: 'why would this be called an investigation if the purpose was to fetch Mr Matlala?' Sehas: 'Anything being done on whether it is transfer, court duties, whatever, Commissioner, is called investigation in a memorandum.' Madlanga: 'Why?' Sehas: 'There is no specific reason.' The approved version came back from Perumal rather than from Sehas, carrying the additional signature of Advocate Annemarie Friedman, then the acting Investigating Director, and the word urgent. Both versions still carried a typing error in the subject line giving the year as 2024.

The journey, and what the commissioners made of the security of it

They left Brummeria on the morning of 8 April 2026 and reached Ebongweni at about 14:30. Only Padayachee's vehicle was let inside; Sehas went in with him and the two of them took acceptance of Matlala, signing the Correctional Services form 'remand detainee released to SAPS / correctional facility' at the bottom of which the number of prisoners is given as 01. They were back on the road at about 15:40. Commissioner Khumalo SC took the risk head on. 'You were transporting Mr Matlala in white VW Polos?' 'Without backup, without Task Force backup, without security?' 'Was he cuffed?' 'And he was in the back of a white VW Polo?' 'Six hours from KZN to Pretoria?' Sehas's answers were all yes, except the last: 'It was a little bit less, Commissioner.' Khumalo then put it plainly: 'That is a high risk. I mean, IDAC people could have been ambushed. There could have been an attempt to escape... I know a VW Polo, it is not the sort of vehicle you use to transport high-profile awaiting trial prisoners.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner, I agree.' He told the commission this was his first such transfer, that IDAC does not routinely move prisoners because its accused are usually on bail or held at a station, and that the only security the convoy carried was that its members are armed and military trained: 'we are also military-trained members, and we are armed, so if that changes the ball game, I would say, Commissioner.' Madlanga did not accept that as an answer: 'But that is not really your function. You are not specialist in the field, unless you are to tell me that there was no reason in the first place for Mr Matlala to have been taken to the most secure prison facility in the country.' Sehas: 'I cannot answer on that, Commissioners.' Madlanga: 'Which would raise its own questions then.' Commissioner Baloyi SC asked whether the Emergency Support Team had been asked to assist; Sehas said Padayachee had been speaking to its commander at Kgosi Mampuru and that he assumed either an agreement or a reluctance, but to his own knowledge no request was made. He also confirmed that Matlala's legal representatives were not told, and that he assumed the lead investigating officer and Perumal would have done it.

The stops, in the order the record gives them

Sehas drove the third car and did not have Matlala in sight for the whole trip. At the BP garage at Nottingham Road the team refuelled and swapped around, and Financial Investigator Phaleni Ngobeni took Sehas's place in Padayachee's car. Asked by Khumalo SC what was happening in the back on the way up, whether Matlala was being interviewed or signing affidavits, Sehas said no: 'he was reluctant to speak', the questions were general ones about his treatment in prison, 'and then he will answer and he will look out the window'. Nothing relating to the case was discussed in his hearing. Outside Johannesburg, Sehas left the convoy to drop a colleague who lives in Johannesburg South and rejoined on the N14 near Jean Avenue in Centurion. Baloyi SC drew the consequence: 'you did not always have him within your sight. You do not know what happened in that period when you diverted.' Sehas: 'No, no, Commissioner.' At the Jean Avenue island Padayachee pulled the convoy over and said 'we needed to go to the Chief quickly'. Nobody in the other two cars knew where they were going. They drove into town past the University of South Africa and stopped in front of the Sheraton Hotel in Arcadia, where Perumal came out of the hotel and got into Padayachee's vehicle. Sehas puts that at after eleven, 'maybe 10 past, quarter past 11 in the evening'. Asked why Perumal was at the hotel, he said: 'I think he was staying there, Commissioner, because he is from out of the province.' The cars turned left at Church Street, and the following drivers believed they were going to the prison. Instead they went to the McDonald's on Skinner Street. Ngobeni got out and ate with the others behind the cars. Perumal, Padayachee and Matlala stayed in the stationary vehicle. Perumal bought Matlala food. 'The three of them were in the stationary vehicle for approximately 40 to 45 minutes.'

The gate, and the question the commission still cannot answer

They reached Kgosi Mampuru II around midnight, 'about 10 minutes before or 10 minutes after'. At the gate Padayachee got out and told the team that 'the Chief, referring to Chief Perumal, thanks us for a job well done and that we were being decommissioned'. They went home on the assumption that Perumal and Padayachee would book Matlala in. Sehas does not know when that happened, or whether it happened as described. Commissioner Baloyi SC spent the rest of the topic on what his signature at Ebongweni had meant. 'You are released into your joint custody from eBongweni. You get to Kgosi Mampuru, you do not sign him in as one of the co-signatories. You actually are happy to leave the other two, one of whom was not a signatory at eBongweni... That seems at best is reckless on your part. But in fact, my sense is there is something unlawful about it, that you signed out a prisoner and you are not the one that delivers him back. In fact, you do not know what happened to him.' Sehas: 'That is correct, Commissioner.' Earlier, in the McDonald's parking lot, she had put the whole shape of the night to him in one question: 'Surely it dawns on you at this point that this is not right, what is happening. You have a prisoner that you are driving around town in the middle of the night.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner.' The one factual hole the commission flagged on its own record is the booking-in time. Advocate Motlhasedi: 'the Commission has made, has taken steps to try and obtain information about what time Mr Matlala was received at C-Max. We have not yet received that confirmation as yet.' Until it arrives, as Baloyi SC put it, 'we have only his word that he was booked in at around four in the morning'.

Matlala's own account, read back to the man who drove the convoy

The commission then did something it rarely does in public: it put one witness's transcript to another. Advocate Motlhasedi took Sehas to an extract from Matlala's evidence of 11 November 2026, in which Commissioner Khumalo SC had asked him about the Sheraton. Matlala: 'they went to eBongweni and booked me out from eBongweni, and that is when they drove with me to Sheraton Hotel... we found Perumal in Sheraton Hotel, and that is when we had these discussions about how they want to nail these three Generals and the others.' Motlhasedi put each limb to Sehas in turn. The collection from Ebongweni: consistent. Finding Perumal at the Sheraton: consistent. The McDonald's: consistent. The discussion about the generals: 'Not the conversation itself, Commissioners.' Khumalo SC pressed: 'were you part of these discussions to nail the three Generals?' Sehas: 'Not at all, Commissioner.' 'But did you hear that discussion?' 'No, no, Commissioner. I was not in that vehicle.' This is the exact line this archive drew on the night and the record holds it. The journey and the stops are now described from both sides. What Matlala says was wanted from him in the car is corroborated by nobody, and the two officials said to have been in it with him have answered nothing. The accounts also diverge on the clock: Matlala puts the Sheraton at two or three in the morning and the prison at four; Sehas says eleven and midnight and says he keeps a written record of times at each point. The commission did not resolve it.

The afternoon: a chief superintendent, a dictated statement and four clips

Chief Superintendent Emosacia Tintswalo Rikhotso has been in the Johannesburg Metropolitan Police Department since 2003 and was promoted to her present rank in October 2025; in August 2023, when the events happened, she was an inspector, which is why this archive carries both ranks. Her statement to the commission is short. She did not know the JMPD officer Eric Mphahlele before his arrest for the robbery and theft of R1.5 million from Mr Nawazish Ali Raja. Her colleague of twenty years, Inspector Immaculate Emma Florence Phakoane, asked her to help confirm the arrest and then to help with bail, and she agreed 'in good faith in line with the law'. She obtained the number of a DPCI officer, Captain Matimu Mabunda, through her sister Dolly, drove to the Hawks offices in the Vaal, and attended a short meeting outside the Brixton 10-111 Flying Squad offices with Mabunda, Captain Tauatswala, Warrant Officer Phuti Mashala and Phakoane. On the bribe she is categorical: 'I did not offer any bribe to the investigators to squash or facilitate the disappearance of the case docket in the criminal case against Mr Mphahlele. I did not offer any bribe money to anyone in this regard.' Advocate Thabang Pooe's cross-examination did not argue with that statement. It set it against three other accounts Rikhotso has given of the same events: the handwritten statement she made to the Hawks at Germiston on 28 August 2023, the recorded interview she gave DPCI investigator Captain Manda three months later, and the account she gave this commission's own investigators in 2026. The recording of the Manda interview reached the commission late the night before the hearing and was played in four clips.

What is on the recording, and what she says about it

The first clip opens with the question of how her own case links to the Mphahlele docket. Rikhotso, in her own voice: 'I went and take the money with the police, the investigating officer.' Asked what the money was for, she says the bail. Asked how she got involved, she says she saw it in a WhatsApp group and visited Mphahlele in the cells the next day, and that she got Captain Mabunda's number from her sister Dolly. Advocate Pooe took her through it line by line against the handwritten statement and showed that the two match. Later clips go further: the figure of R800 000 that she says Warrant Officer Mashala named; a drive to Springs to collect cash; the money in a plastic bag; handing it to Mabunda, who told her to put it on the front passenger seat and cover it with a laptop bag; and a distribution: 'in other words this amount of money it is going to be distributed amongst the...' and her answer naming the head of the DPCI and a magistrate, with 'the bail issue'. Then the threats, from Mphahlele's cousin, 'that I eat the money, I must get the money'. Her position on all of it is that the handwritten statement was dictated to her by Phakoane and by a DPCI officer she would name only as Carlo, and that in the interview she was reciting what she had written. The commissioners did not accept the architecture of that answer. Baloyi SC: 'She could not have told you to write what implicates her. It does not make sense. If she is dictating to you, how does she implicate herself and tell you, tell them that I am collecting money, which you repeat in the clip.' Khumalo SC: 'But how are you protecting her? You are saying she collected the money, she was going to use it to bribe Matimu and other police officers. How does that protect her?' And the harder point, which she conceded: in 2026, years after she says she learned the truth about Phakoane, she gave this commission's investigators the same account again. Advocate Pooe: 'that was a choice you made to come and lie to the Commission's investigators.' Rikhotso: 'I did not lie.' Pooe: 'I think the record is very clear that you are lying.'

The syndicate, and the chairperson's question

Baloyi SC laid out three possibilities for her and asked her to choose one: that she was paid to lie, that she was in the scheme and had a share coming, or that she was genuinely afraid, in which case she had to say of what. Rikhotso took the third. 'I was not paid to lie. I did not receive anything. And then I was not part of the scheme. I was scared of my life. I found out that this is a syndicate that involves a lot of people... they mentioned names that I can be killed if I change what I wrote in the statement. That is the honest truth.' Khumalo SC asked what the syndicate was and whether she had reported it; she said it runs across JMPD and 'other stakeholders', which under the chairperson's questioning she narrowed to the Hawks and to informers. She named three JMPD members she knew of and said she had not reported what she knew to the Chief of Police because a case was already pending in Internal Affairs, and that she is not the complainant in it. The chairperson then asked for the method, and twice had to tell her not to retreat into not understanding the question: 'No, no, please. Please do not trifle with us. Do not trifle with us. What do you know them to do?' Her answer is the clearest description of the Raja robbery pattern anyone has given this commission: 'They wait for them. The informers tell them the time they victim will be driving or passing in this and they target them, they stop them and they rob them', knowing from the informer that the person will be carrying cash. She said she first understood this when, as she put it, Phakoane went back to rob Mr Raja a second time. Advocate Pooe placed the date on the record from Captain Manda's statement: 18 December 2023, and noted that when the investigators reached the scene they found Captain Carlo there, and that he did not follow them to the police station. Asked directly what the relationship was between Phakoane and Carlo, Rikhotso asked to write it down; told to speak, she said: 'Romantic.' Advocate Pooe's case, put to her in terms, is that the two of them reported their own bribery to Carlo precisely because they knew the enquiry would go nowhere. She denied it. The chairperson's own question was shorter. 'Are you, is this not because perhaps you yourself are part of the syndicate?' 'I am not part of the syndicate.' 'As if you would admit if you were, would you?'

In their words

Key moments from the record

“I am asking because I am trying to think in my mind what reasons there could possibly have been for him to be taken to the most secure prison in the country, and if there were reasons, did it make sense for IDAC to fetch him in the manner in which they did? No backup by SAPS, or no backup even by Correctional Services?”
The chairperson on why a man was fetched from the country's most secure prison in a Polo. Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga to Anthony Sehas, official transcript, Day 197.
“Because, Mr Sehas, look at paragraph 9 of your statement. Mr Matlala was taken from Mampuru by a Tactical Response Team and an Emergency Support Team. But when he comes back, it is just VW Polos.”
Taken by two tactical units, brought back by three Polos. Commissioner Advocate Sandile Khumalo SC to Sehas, on paragraph 9 of his own statement.
“KHUMALO SC: So would you say what was done on that day is consistent with the protocol that you are aware of? SEHAS: No, Commissioner. KHUMALO SC: Something went wrong. SEHAS: Yes, Commissioner. KHUMALO SC: Terribly wrong. SEHAS: Yes, yes, Commissioner.”
The concession, in the commissioner's words. Khumalo SC and Sehas, on whether the night followed any protocol.
“So at that stage, it was only Mr Perumal, Mr Padayachee and Mr Matlala in that vehicle. Mr Perumal bought Mr Matlala food as well. We do not know what, if anything, was discussed because we were out of the vehicle. The three of them were in the stationary vehicle for approximately 40 to 45 minutes.”
Forty-five minutes he cannot account for. Sehas reading paragraph 28 of his witness statement into the record, on the McDonald's stop on Skinner Street.
“You are now parked at McDonald's. You are standing outside. The other two are in the vehicle with him for 45 minutes. He is not at Kgosi Mampuru since you left. Surely it dawns on you at this point that this is not right, what is happening. You have a prisoner that you are driving around town in the middle of the night.”
A commissioner puts the night to him in one question. Commissioner Advocate Sesi Baloyi SC to Sehas, in the McDonald's parking lot passage.
“That seems at best is reckless on your part. But in fact, my sense is there is something unlawful about it, that you signed out a prisoner and you are not the one that delivers him back. In fact, you do not know what happened to him.”
Signed out by two men, signed in by neither. Baloyi SC to Sehas, on his signature at Ebongweni and the release of the team at the Kgosi Mampuru gate.
“MOTLHASEDI: Could you there be referring to the same grouping that Advocate Drushantha spoke about before the Commission? SEHAS: It could be. It is the members that comes from the Eastern Cape, ja.”
The quarter inside IDAC that works among itself. Advocate Motlhasedi putting Advocate Drushantha Ramsamy's earlier evidence of an 'Eastern Cape team' to Sehas, who had used similar language in paragraph 37 of his own statement.
“MALE SPEAKER: When you said your case that you opened is linked with that case, how is it linked with that case? RIKHOTSO: I went and take the money with the police, the investigating officer.”
Her own voice, played back to her. Chief Superintendent Rikhotso in her 2023 recorded interview with DPCI investigator Captain Manda, clip one, played in open session on Day 197. She told the commission this account was untrue and had been dictated to her.
“She could not have told you to write what implicates her. It does not make sense. If she is dictating to you, how does she implicate herself and tell you, tell them that I am collecting money, which you repeat in the clip. It does not make sense. Human beings do not behave that way.”
Why the dictation defence did not satisfy the panel. Commissioner Baloyi SC to Rikhotso, on the claim that Inspector Emma Phakoane dictated a statement that incriminated Phakoane herself.
“No, no, please. Please do not trifle with us. Do not trifle with us. What do you know them to do? What do you understand them to do?”
The chairperson on a witness who kept not understanding the question. Madlanga to Rikhotso, after she said she did not understand a question about the syndicate's method, having earlier given the same answer about a question on who made a phone call.
“They wait for them. The informers tell them the time they victim will be driving or passing in this and they target them, they stop them and they rob them.”
How the syndicate works, in her own description. Rikhotso to Madlanga, describing the method she says she learned of after the second attempt on Mr Raja.
“MADLANGA: You are so, so not forthcoming and self-contradictory... Are you, is this not because perhaps you yourself are part of the syndicate? RIKHOTSO: I am not part of the syndicate. MADLANGA: As if you would admit if you were, would you?”
The question the chairperson asked last. Madlanga to Rikhotso, at the close of the day. It is a question, not a finding, and she denied it.

Our analysis

The bottom line

The two halves of this day look unrelated and are the same story told at two ranks. In the morning a national anti-corruption directorate moved a high-profile prisoner across the country on a piece of paper that named no prisoner, with no escort, with a stop to collect a senior official from a hotel at eleven at night and three quarters of an hour parked outside a fast-food outlet, and then released the officers who had signed for him without any of them signing him in. In the afternoon a metro police officer described a system in which informers tell officers when a business person will be carrying cash so that the officers can stop the car and take it. Both are accounts of state power being used for a purpose the paperwork does not disclose. The commission's own mandate is the infiltration of the criminal justice system, and neither witness was describing infiltration from outside. Both were describing officials using their own lawful authority off the books.

On Sehas the record is stronger than the reporting in one specific respect and weaker in another. Stronger: the travel memorandum is now in evidence and it is the hard document of the day. A memorandum that says investigation and gives a case number, and does not say that a man is to be taken out of the highest-security prison in the country, is a document that cannot be reviewed by the person signing it. Baloyi SC's question about Ms De Swardt was not really about Ms De Swardt. It was about whether an approval process that cannot see what it is approving is an approval process at all, and Sehas agreed that it is how IDAC does things. Weaker: Sehas cannot take the central allegation anywhere, and he was careful not to try. He was in another car. He did not hear the conversation about the generals. He does not know what was said in the forty-five minutes. The evidence that corroborates Matlala is evidence about geography and clocks, not about content, and this archive will not let the two blur.

Rikhotso's evidence is the harder problem, and it is harder for the commission than for her. A witness who says four accounts of the same events are false because they were dictated, and that the fifth is true, is asking to be believed on the basis of nothing but the fifth account. Commissioner Baloyi SC named the difficulty exactly: the dictated statement incriminates the person said to have dictated it, which is not how a person protecting themselves writes. But the opposite reading has a difficulty of its own that nobody put to her. If she was in the scheme and the money went where the recording says it went, then going to the Hawks at Germiston to report it, on oath, in writing, with her name on it, is an extraordinary thing to have done. Advocate Pooe's answer to that was the romantic relationship between Phakoane and the DPCI officer who took the statements, which would mean the report was safe to make because it was never going anywhere. That is a coherent theory. It is also, at this stage, a theory put to a witness who denied it, and the officer concerned is identified on the public record by a first name only and has answered nothing.

What this archive will not do is treat a witness's unreliability as proof of her guilt, and that is a live risk with this page. Three commissioners and an evidence leader told her, in terms, that they did not believe her. That is a judgment on credibility made in open session by people entitled to make it, and it is recorded here because it happened. It is not a finding that she offered a bribe, took a bribe or belongs to a syndicate, and the commission has made no such finding. The things that are established are narrow: that she gave a sworn statement in 2023, that she repeated its contents to a DPCI investigator in a recorded interview, that she repeated them again to this commission's investigators in 2026, and that she now says all of it was untrue. Which account is true is exactly the question the commission exists to answer, and it has not answered it yet.

Two threads to watch. The first is the booking-in time at Kgosi Mampuru II: the commission has asked Correctional Services for it and has not been given it, and it is the one piece of paper that would settle whether Matlala reached the prison at midnight or at four in the morning. The second is the Eastern Cape grouping inside IDAC, which now has two witnesses using almost the same language about it from different positions in the organisation. Neither witness alleged a crime by that group. Both described a working practice of controlling information, which is the condition in which a night like 8 April 2026 becomes possible.

Analysis is the archive’s own comment on the public proceedings, grounded in the record above. It weighs the evidence and the process; questions of individual guilt are for the courts and the commission to decide. Everyone named is presumed innocent.

Follow the threads

Who Anthony Winston Sehas connects to

The prisoner whose transfer he described

Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala

Matlala alleged on Day 190 that IDAC officials booked him out of custody and took him to a McDonald's and to the Sheraton Hotel rather than back to prison. On Day 197 Sehas gave the directorate's own account of a journey with those stops in it, and the commission read Matlala's transcript back to him. The corroboration covers the journey and the stops, not what Matlala says was asked of him; Sehas was in another vehicle and heard none of it. Both men's accounts of the latter remain untested, and the two diverge on the time of arrival at Kgosi Mampuru II.

View profile →
The chief investigator he placed in the stationary car

Dylan Perumal

On the Day 197 transcript, Sehas said Perumal signed the approved travel memorandum as acting head of investigations and operations, came out of the Sheraton Hotel in Arcadia after 23:00 and got into the vehicle carrying Matlala, bought him food at the McDonald's on Skinner Street, and remained in that stationary vehicle with him and Padayachee for about forty-five minutes. Sehas was outside the car and cannot say what was discussed. Perumal was suspended on 30 July 2026 pending a disciplinary process, has never testified here, and has answered none of it. He is presumed innocent.

View profile →
The senior investigator who led the convoy

Colonel Brian Padayachee

On the Day 197 transcript, Padayachee asked Sehas to collect him from the airport on 7 April 2026, drove the vehicle carrying Matlala, co-signed the Correctional Services release form at Ebongweni, pulled the convoy over at Jean Avenue to divert to the Sheraton, was one of the two officials in the stationary car at the McDonald's, and told the team at the prison gate that the Chief thanked them for a job well done and that they were decommissioned. Sehas said the questions Padayachee put to Matlala during the drive were general ones about prison conditions and that nothing about the case was discussed in his hearing. Padayachee testified across Days 139 to 141, before this evidence existed, and has not answered it. Presumed innocent.

View profile →
The second witness to describe the same grouping inside IDAC

Advocate Drushantha Ramsamy

Ramsamy told the commission about a clique inside IDAC that worked exclusively among itself and controlled the flow of information, which the evidence leader called the Eastern Cape team. Sehas used almost the same language in his own statement and, asked whether he meant the same grouping, answered: 'It could be. It is the members that comes from the Eastern Cape, ja.' Neither witness alleged a crime by that group; both described a working practice. Nobody named has answered it here and all are presumed innocent.

View profile →