Madlanga Commission hearing record
Day 196 of the Madlanga Commission
Witness: Clive Naicker
A numbered sitting with no public record at all. Clive Naicker resumed behind closed doors on the half of his evidence the chairperson had sealed: what passed between him and members of Crime Intelligence and the Hawks. Nothing from the room is public, and nothing on this page comes from it.
The day in brief
What you need to know
- NO EVIDENCE FROM THIS DAY IS PUBLIC AND NONE IS ON THIS PAGE. The commission published no summary and no video for it, which is what it does for every closed sitting, and no transcript exists or will exist. Everything below comes from the public Day 195 record and the signed ruling that created this day, not from the sealed room.
- THE RULING THAT MADE THIS DAY. Dated at Pretoria on 15 November 2026 and signed by the Commission Secretary Dr N Vukuza, it split Clive Naicker's evidence in two. Open: his relationship with the late Bevan Loftus and whether he was involved in events that may have resulted in the killing; the nature of his business activities; and whether he paid moneys to police officers and why. Closed: 'the nature of his interaction with members of the SAPS Crime Intelligence and DPCI' and 'the evidence relating to court going matters in which Mr Clive Naicker is currently a witness'. He had applied for all of it to be closed.
- THE SEALED HALF IS THE HALF CLOSEST TO THIS COMMISSION'S MANDATE. This inquiry exists to examine criminality and corruption inside the criminal justice system. What passed between a tow-truck operator and members of Crime Intelligence and the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation is precisely that subject, and it is the part the public will not hear.
- A SEPARATE AND UNCONNECTED FACT FALLS ON THE SAME DATE. On 17 November 2026 Tamryn Raju, 32, was shot dead inside her home in Shastri Park, Phoenix. She was the daughter of the man Naicker had described from the stand the previous day as his uncle, and she had spent the preceding fortnight publicly disputing his account of her father's killing. No motive has been established, no arrest has been made and nobody has been named by police. That the two things share a date is a fact. That they are connected is not, and this archive asserts no link.
Full coverage
The day, in depth
What a numbered closed day is, and why it still gets a page
The commission numbers its closed sittings in the same sequence as its public ones. Day 182, on 6 October 2026, was the first; this is the second since. The official hearings row exists, carries the date and carries nothing else: no summary, no video, no transcript in the open uploads directory. This archive gives such a day a page for one reason, which is that a reader following the day sequence must not find a hole where a sitting was. The page says what is known about why the day was closed and says plainly that the evidence is not public. Nothing is inferred about its contents from the fact that it was sealed.
How the previous day ended
Naicker gave a full working day of open evidence on Monday 16 November 2026 and the 182-page transcript of it is public. The chairperson dealt with the in camera application before the first question and told the room the ruling had been made the previous night: the testimony would be 'partly in-camera and partly in open session. So we are going to start with that part, which will be in open session, and as soon as we are done, we will then break to resume in-camera.' He warned counsel repeatedly to keep the two halves apart, 'so that you do not let slip inadvertently what should be in-camera', and directed that the witness statement itself not be shown on the public feed because the part below the line being read might describe a relationship that belonged to the closed half. The Day 195 record ends 'HEARING POSTPONED TO 17 NOVEMBER 2026' with the direction: 'Let us resume in camera at 09:30 tomorrow.'
Our analysis
The bottom line
A commission that holds closed sittings has to be trusted twice: once that it was right to close the room, and once that what happens inside it is the same inquiry that happens outside. The second is unverifiable by anyone outside. This archive records closed days as closed rather than treating silence as nothing happening, and resists the temptation to speculate about what a sealed session contained, because a guess published in an archive hardens into a fact faster than it would anywhere else.
The specific loss here is worth naming. The open half of Naicker's evidence dealt with a recorded phone call, a tow-truck business and a set of denials. The closed half deals with his interaction with Crime Intelligence and the Hawks. The first is the story; the second is the mandate. The commission had a reason for the split and it gave one, which is that he is a witness in live court matters. Both things can be true: that the closure was justified, and that it removed from public view the material this commission was created to examine.
Analysis is the archive’s own comment on the public proceedings, grounded in the record above. It weighs the evidence and the process; questions of individual guilt are for the courts and the commission to decide. Everyone named is presumed innocent.
On the record
Who testified this day
Follow the threads
Who Clive Naicker connects to
Bevan Loftus
Named by the deceased's father as a competitor in the tow-truck industry and as the person at whose instance the killing allegedly occurred. The official Day 195 transcript shows the recorded call between them carried accusations in both directions: Loftus accused Naicker of putting a price on his head, and Naicker accused Loftus of killing his uncle. Untested; presumed innocent.
View profile →The witness who named himGregory Loftus
Gregory Loftus's Day 158 evidence is the source of the allegation recorded on this page. Naicker answered it on oath on Day 195 and denied it. Untested on both sides; presumed innocent.
View profile →The officer alleged to have been paid by a tow-truck ownerLieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender
IPID alleged that the task-team commander received more than R2.5 million from the owner of a tow-truck company between August 2022 and December 2023. On Day 170 Govender denied any payment from Naicker and described their relationship as work-related and not personal. On Day 195 Naicker denied offering any reward to any police officer. Both denials are on the record; untested, and both men are presumed innocent.
View profile →The IPID investigator whose evidence quantified the paymentsLen Barnabas John
Len John's evidence of 12 August 2026 put more than R2.5 million from a tow-truck company owner to the task-team commander between August 2022 and December 2023, and more than R2.7 million connected to the killing. Naicker answered that evidence on 16 November 2026 and denied it. Untested.
View profile →The firearms expert who questioned the police accountAshley Houston
Houston attended the Morningside scene and told the commission on 13 August 2026 that the officers' account of the shooting was 'highly improbable'. His evidence goes to how the five men died, not to who, if anyone, procured it.
View profile →His relative, killed the day after he testifiedTamryn Raju
Per SABC News she was a relative of his; per Daily Maverick and IOL she was the daughter of the uncle he described from the stand on Day 195, and in the days before she died she publicly disputed his account that Bevan Loftus was responsible for her father's killing. She was shot dead at her Phoenix home on 17 November 2026, the day he was due to resume his evidence in camera. Police have established no motive, have made no arrest and have named nobody. No link to the commission or to any person has been established, and nothing is alleged here against Naicker.
View profile →In the room & on the record
Counsel, the panel and sources
On the panel
Sources
- Madlanga Commission - official hearings record, Day 196, 17 November 2026 (numbered, no summary and no video published) ↗
- Madlanga Commission - ruling in Naicker's in camera application, 15 November 2026 ↗
- Madlanga Commission - official transcript, Day 195, 16 November 2026 (182 pages), the public half of the same evidence ↗