A travel memorandum that named no prisoner and no purpose
The document authorising the transfer gave a case number and the word investigation, and did not disclose that a man was to be taken out of the country's highest-security prison.
Perumal asked Sehas to draft the travel memorandum. It was addressed to the Director of Administration, Ms Adelle De Swardt, named eight officials and three NPA-issued vehicles, and gave the case number Silverton CAS 285/3/2026, described as an IDAC authorised investigation. It did not name Mr Matlala, did not say a prisoner was to be moved and did not state the nature of the matter. The chairperson asked first: 'why would this be called an investigation if the purpose was to fetch Mr Matlala?' Sehas: 'Anything being done on whether it is transfer, court duties, whatever, Commissioner, is called investigation in a memorandum.' Justice Madlanga: 'Why?' Sehas: 'There is no specific reason.' Commissioner Sesi Baloyi SC drew the consequence: the approving official 'would not have known that she is, in fact, approving the transportation of a Correctional Services person, or a person who is in the custody, in fact, of Correctional Services. She would not have known that is what she is approving.' Sehas: 'No, Commissioner.' Asked why the memorandum omitted the case and the name, he said: 'the memorandum passes through a lot of hands, so it is also a way of protecting information and not putting too much out to the wrong person.' The approved version came back from Perumal rather than from Sehas, carried the word urgent and added the signature of Advocate Annemarie Friedman, then the acting Investigating Director. Both versions still gave the year in the subject line as 2024, an error Sehas confirmed on the record.
Taken to Ebongweni by two tactical units, brought back by three Polos
The commissioners put the asymmetry of the two journeys to him and he accepted it in terms.
Sehas's statement records that when the team reached Kgosi Mampuru II on 7 April 2026 they were told a SAPS Tactical Response Team and the Correctional Services Emergency Support Team had transferred Matlala to Ebongweni the previous weekend. Commissioner Sandile Khumalo SC put the return journey against it: 'Mr Matlala was taken from Mampuru by a Tactical Response Team and an Emergency Support Team. But when he comes back, it is just VW Polos.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'That is concerning.' Sehas: 'It is, Commissioner.' Earlier in the same exchange Khumalo had asked: 'You were transporting Mr Matlala in white VW Polos?' 'Without backup, without Task Force backup, without security?' 'Was he cuffed?' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner, with leg irons and handcuffs.' Khumalo: 'Six hours from KZN to Pretoria?' Sehas: 'It was a little bit less, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'That is a high risk. I mean, IDAC people could have been ambushed. There could have been an attempt to escape. I mean, it is a serious mission to undertake on your own in VW Polos. I mean, I know a VW Polo, it is not the sort of vehicle you use to transport high-profile awaiting trial prisoners.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner, I agree.' He told the commission it was his first such transfer, that IDAC does not routinely move prisoners because its accused are usually on bail or held at a station, and that the vehicles were standard rather than bulletproof. Commissioner Baloyi SC asked whether the Emergency Support Team had been asked to help; Sehas said Padayachee had been in contact with its commander and that he assumed either an agreement or a reluctance, but that to his own knowledge no request was made.
The chairperson asked whether the journey made sense at all
Justice Madlanga went to the premise rather than the detail, and refused the answer that the officials were armed.
Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga: 'Do you know why Mr Matlala had been taken to eBongweni, the most secure prison facility in South Africa?' Sehas: 'No, Commissioner, I did not.' Madlanga: 'I am asking because I am trying to think in my mind what reasons there could possibly have been for him to be taken to the most secure prison in the country, and if there were reasons, did it make sense for IDAC to fetch him in the manner in which they did? No backup by SAPS, or no backup even by Correctional Services?' Sehas: 'Well, we are also military-trained members, and we are armed, so if that changes the ball game, I would say, Commissioner.' Madlanga: 'But that is not really your function. You are not specialist in the field, unless you are to tell me that there was no reason in the first place for Mr Matlala to have been taken to the most secure prison facility in the country.' Sehas: 'I cannot answer on that, Commissioners.' Madlanga: 'Which would raise its own questions then.' Sehas: 'Yes, yes, Commissioner, I agree.' The chairperson separately asked what financial investigators were doing on a prisoner transfer at all; Sehas said all IDAC investigators have the same policing powers and that the financial staff were there 'just to post to the numbers, if I can put it like that'.
The stops after 23:00, and the forty-five minutes he could not account for
A man in custody sat in a stationary car with two investigators outside a McDonald's for about forty-five minutes, four or five kilometres from the prison, and the witness was outside it.
Sehas drove the third car. At the BP garage at Nottingham Road the team refuelled and swapped around and Financial Investigator Phaleni Ngobeni took his seat in Padayachee's vehicle. Outside Johannesburg Sehas left the convoy to drop a colleague in Johannesburg South and rejoined on the N14; Commissioner Baloyi SC drew the consequence that he did not have Matlala in sight throughout and does not know what happened in that period, which he accepted. At the island before the Jean Avenue off-ramp in Centurion, Padayachee pulled the convoy over and said 'we needed to go to the Chief quickly'. Nobody in the other two cars knew where they were going. They stopped in front of the Sheraton Hotel in Arcadia, where Perumal came out and got into Padayachee's vehicle: 'we were maybe stationary for 45 seconds, and then we went to McDonald's.' Sehas puts that at after eleven, 'maybe 10 past, quarter past 11 in the evening', and said he believed Perumal was staying there 'because he is from out of the province'. The following drivers thought they were going to the prison, which was 'about four or five kilometres down the road'. Instead the convoy went to the McDonald's on Skinner Street in the Pretoria CBD. From his statement, read into the record: 'When we arrived at the parking lot of the McDonald's, Mr Ngobeni got out of the car and he was with us eating... So at that stage, it was only Mr Perumal, Mr Padayachee and Mr Matlala in that vehicle. Mr Perumal bought Mr Matlala food as well. We do not know what, if anything, was discussed because we were out of the vehicle. The three of them were in the stationary vehicle for approximately 40 to 45 minutes.' Commissioner Baloyi SC: 'Surely it dawns on you at this point that this is not right, what is happening. You have a prisoner that you are driving around town in the middle of the night.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner.'
He signed the prisoner out and never signed him back in
At the prison gate the team was told the Chief thanked them for a job well done and was released. The commission has asked Correctional Services for the booking-in time and has not received it.
At Ebongweni, Sehas and Padayachee co-signed the Correctional Services form recording the release of one remand detainee into their custody for transfer to Kgosi Mampuru II C-Max. They reached that prison around midnight, 'about 10 minutes before or 10 minutes after'. From his statement: 'Mr Padayachee then got out of the car and informed us that the Chief, referring to Chief Perumal, thanks us for a job well done and that we were being decommissioned. We were released and we can go home. The team was then released and we then left, went home on the assumption that Mr Perumal and Mr Padayachee would formally book Mr Matlala in at the Kgosi Mampuru prison.' Commissioner Baloyi SC: 'you signed out a prisoner and you are not the one that delivers him back. In fact, you do not know what happened to him.' Sehas: 'That is correct, Commissioner.' She went further: 'That seems at best is reckless on your part. But in fact, my sense is there is something unlawful about it.' On protocol, Commissioner Khumalo SC asked whether what was done that day was consistent with the protocols he knew; Sehas: 'No, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'Something went wrong.' Sehas: 'Yes, Commissioner.' Khumalo: 'Terribly wrong.' Sehas: 'Yes, yes, Commissioner.' Advocate Motlhasedi told the record that the commission had taken steps to obtain the time at which Matlala was received at C-Max and had not received that confirmation. Matlala's own evidence puts it at four in the morning; Sehas says around midnight and says he keeps written times at each point of a journey. Neither account is tested.
What this does, and does not do, to Matlala's own account
The journey and the stops are now described from both sides. What Matlala says was wanted from him in the car is corroborated by nobody.
The commission put Matlala's own transcript of 11 November 2026 to Sehas. Matlala had told Commissioner Khumalo SC: 'they went to eBongweni and booked me out from eBongweni, and that is when they drove with me to Sheraton Hotel... we found Perumal in Sheraton Hotel, and that is when we had these discussions about how they want to nail these three Generals and the others.' Advocate Motlhasedi put each limb to Sehas. The collection from Ebongweni, consistent. Finding Perumal at the Sheraton, consistent. The McDonald's, consistent. The conversation about the generals: 'Not the conversation itself, Commissioners.' Khumalo SC: 'were you part of these discussions to nail the three Generals?' Sehas: 'Not at all, Commissioner.' 'But did you hear that discussion?' 'No, no, Commissioner. I was not in that vehicle.' Asked what was said during the drive itself, he said Matlala 'was reluctant to speak', that Padayachee asked general questions about his treatment in prison, 'and then he will answer and he will look out the window', and that nothing relating to the case was discussed in his hearing. The corroboration therefore goes to the journey and the stops, which are now described from both sides. It does not corroborate what Matlala says was wanted from him in those meetings, which no witness has confirmed and which the officials named have never answered. The two accounts also diverge on the clock, and the commission did not resolve that.
A quarter inside IDAC that worked among itself
His statement describes a group that tightly controlled information, and he agreed it was the grouping another witness had called the Eastern Cape team.
The final paragraph of his statement reads: 'This is largely because a certain quarter of IDAC generally worked amongst themselves and tightly controlled the flow of information on matters on which they were working.' Asked what that referred to, he said it was the team allocated to the Medicare matter and to what the commission has heard called project diversion. Advocate Motlhasedi put to him that the advocate Drushantha Ramsamy had described to this commission a clique she called the Eastern Cape team in almost the same language. Sehas: 'It could be. It is the members that comes from the Eastern Cape, ja.' Asked who, he named five of the officials listed in his own paragraph 36. He also told the commission that the IDAC prosecutors involved in the plea and sentencing agreement negotiations with Matlala were Mr Rikus Kriel and Advocate Santhos Manilall, and that he himself had no knowledge of the Medicare investigation. The description is of an informal working practice, not an allegation of a crime by any individual, and none of the people he named has answered it before this commission. All are presumed innocent.