Instructed by the police minister to run a parallel investigation
In early January 2025 then police minister Senzo Mchunu instructed the Inspector-General's office to investigate, in parallel, the same Crime Intelligence issues Mchunu had referred to IDAC. Reporting by amaBhungane, News24 and the Daily Maverick, drawn from Fazel's own high court affidavit, describes the minister's office as central to the sequence of investigations and leaks that produced both this commission and Fazel's suspension. The affidavit is Fazel's untested account; Mchunu has answered none of it before this commission and is presumed innocent.
He recommended charges against Masemola and Khumalo over R120 million in property
Before his suspension, Fazel recommended disciplinary and criminal charges against national commissioner Lieutenant-General Fannie Masemola and Crime Intelligence head Lieutenant-General Dumisani Khumalo over five properties bought by Crime Intelligence for more than R120 million in 2023 and 2024. That recommendation is a watchdog's opinion, not a charge and not a finding. Neither officer has been convicted of anything arising from it and both are presumed innocent.
Security clearance revoked, then suspended by the President
The State Security Agency withdrew Fazel's security clearance, and three weeks later, in October 2025, President Cyril Ramaphosa suspended him following a complaint. He is challenging both decisions in the high court, arguing the suspension was unprocedural and likely unconstitutional. The President and the other respondents had yet to file their answer when the application was reported in July 2026. These are contested legal proceedings and no court has ruled on them.
Effectively blocked from testifying to this commission
In March 2026 the Daily Maverick reported that the President had effectively blocked the Inspector-General from giving evidence to the Madlanga Commission about the criminal claims he had made against Masemola and Khumalo. The commission has therefore had to deal with his office's work at second hand - through the report Mchunu is alleged to have routed to IDAC, and through witnesses describing contact with his office - rather than from the Inspector-General himself.
Day 164: two sworn accounts of a call from his office
On 21 August 2026 Commissioner Sesi Baloyi confronted MP Fadiel Adams with a contradiction between his evidence to Parliament's ad hoc committee, that Fazel had personally telephoned him about his Crime Intelligence complaint, and his evidence to this commission, that the call came from a member of Fazel's staff. 'How could you possibly mistake a call from such an important person?' she asked. Adams said the parliamentary version was the mistaken one. The dispute is about Adams's reliability, not about any conduct by Fazel, who has not been asked about it and is presumed innocent.
NICOC's own document titles, cleared on 29 October 2026 for use in public hearings, name his office
When Dr Ntandazo Sifolo released most of the National Intelligence Coordinating Committee's documents for use in the commission's open hearings, the redacted schedules were published with the further ruling of 29 October 2026, and two of the six documents in Annexure C that may be displayed in open session are titled 'Concerns Regarding the Activities of the Suspended Inspector-General' and 'Underhanded Machinations of the Inspector-General of Intelligence Regarding Crime Intelligence'; the second is also item 5 of Annexure A, dated there 25 May 2025. The same Annexure C lists a report on an investigation into Crime Intelligence under section 7(7)(c) of the Intelligence Services Oversight Act, a request for access to the Inspector-General's 2024/25 Crime Intelligence oversight project files, and a signed memorandum of understanding between the Inspector-General and IPID. This archive records what those documents are called and nothing more. None has been led in evidence, none has been published, a title is not an allegation and is certainly not a finding, and the characterisations belong to the intelligence structures that authored them. Mr Fazel has been suspended since October 2025, is challenging that suspension in the high court, has been reported as effectively blocked from testifying here about his own criminal referrals, and has answered none of this before this commission. He is presumed innocent.